Starting from the head down, what I thought. "Oh, neat head. Kind of generic monster looking, but it's dark and got the glowing eyes thing down and it looks well done and.." *looks down* "Holy shit bones. Okay now it's creepy. Death Rift indeed."
My god, this thing is creepy as hell, I wish this had been the final choice for the death colossus, I think it is more gruesome and fear inspiring than the one that did win, which really just makes me laugh, it looks so silly.